Birdy Work

Birdy Work

Quick thoughts on the Willson Contreras trade

The Cardinals on Sunday dealt Contreras to the Red Sox in exchange for a package of three pitchers

Dayn Perry's avatar
Dayn Perry
Dec 22, 2025
∙ Paid

I was, coincidentally, driving through Missouri on my from Chicago to Mississippi for the holidays when I heard of the trade that sent Willson Contreras out of St. Louis. My son, tethered to his phone like all other Kids These Days, passed along news of the deal that sends Contreras to the Red Sox in exchange for a trio of right-handed pitchers: Hunter Dobbins, Yhoiker Fajardo, and Blake Aita.

As well, the Cardinals included $8 million in cash in the deal to defray Contreras’ remaining commitment (he’s owed at least $41.5 million over the next two seasons). Straightaway, that’s notable and laudable. The DeWitts approved a cash inclusion in the Sonny Gray trade with Boston, but this one comes very soon after the Cardinals learned that FanDuel Sports Network’s parent company, Main Street Sports Group, wouldn’t be making its December rights payment to the club. Ownership had previously indicated they would be willing to help pay down contracts in trades, but it’s good to see it happen after yet another potential hit to the revenue stream.

As for the return, to my thinking it’s an impressive one considering that Contreras is a righty-righty first baseman – a player type not necessarily coveted by the markets – who’s going into his age-34 season. As well, Contreras’ full no-trade clause limited the demand side of the equation. Those are important contexts, and Chaim Bloom and company did well in light of them.

Birdy Work is an independent and a reader-supported publication devoted to the St. Louis Cardinals. Paid subscription plans are available at the cheapest rates Substack will allow — $5 per month or $30 per year. Paid subscribers get regular subscriber-only posts, including occasional reader mailbags; timely reactions to breaking Cardinals news; the ability to post comments on all posts; and free access to a private Slack channel to discuss the Cardinals with me and your fellow paid subscribers. This kind of essential support ensures that Birdy Work can continue. I thank you for your consideration.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Dayn Perry.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2025 Dayn Perry · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture